News
Information on Critiques
Written on 04.11.2026 12:04 by Sumair Ijaz Hashmi
Dear all,
The slides from last session (on how to critique a paper) and the grading criteria for critiques are also on CMS. These are the main documents which you need to write down your critiques for this proseminar.
We’ve posted example critiques for the two papers we’ve already discussed: the Experts vs. Non-Experts paper and the Forced PINs paper. You’ll find them in the Materials tab on CMS and on the discussion forum. These examples are for inspiration only. They are not a gold standard, and you don’t need to follow the same structure or line of thinking we used. Please don’t copy our sentences and fill them in with details from the paper you’re reviewing.
Using these materials, please write your first critique on any one compulsory paper from the Hate and Harassment module. To submit:
- Upload a PDF to CMS by 3:00 PM on Monday, 9 November. The assignment tab will appear soon.
- After the 3:00 PM deadline, post your critique on the public forum in the thread titled “Hate & Harassment.”
Once again, the use of AI tools or copying from each other is strictly prohibited.
If you have any questions, please reach out. Best of luck!
