News

24 November Session + LSF Registration

Written on 19.11.26 by Sumair Ijaz Hashmi

Dear all

Just another reminder to please register on LSF by today. We will not be able to make any exceptions.

And that the assignment tab to submit the next critique is up on CMS.

Best 

(Urgent) Update on LSF Registration

Written on 18.11.26 by Sumair Ijaz Hashmi

Dear all

You should be able to register on LSF now.

Please register on LSF before this Friday 20th November 2026. 

I would appreciate if you could check ASAP and let us know if there are any errors this time.

Best regards and have a wonderful rest of the week!

Update on LSF Registration

Written on 14.11.26 by Sumair Ijaz Hashmi

Dear all

We looked at your concerns and understand that you currently cannot register on LSF. We are currently figuring this out from our end and will get back to you very soon. I am sure everything will work out.

Have a nice weekend!

Registration on LSF

Written on 13.11.26 by Sumair Ijaz Hashmi

Dear All, 

Please register on LSF as soon as possible. We cannot accommodate any late requests for anyone who misses the deadline. You are responsible for your own credits registration.

Thanks

Session on 17 November

Written on 11.11.26 by Sumair Ijaz Hashmi

Hi everyone,

I hope you found the last session on Hate & Harassment useful, both for the module content and as an example of how to put your presentations together.

A few quick updates before the next session:

  • Critique deadlines have changed. The submission tab for the next critique is now… Read more

Hi everyone,

I hope you found the last session on Hate & Harassment useful, both for the module content and as an example of how to put your presentations together.

A few quick updates before the next session:

  • Critique deadlines have changed. The submission tab for the next critique is now open on CMS. Following your suggestion in class, all critiques are now due on Sundays: 5 PM on CMS and 7 PM on the discussion forum. These times apply for the rest of the course.
  • Presentation template: We’ve uploaded the CISPA presentation template for PowerPoint and Keynote to the Materials tab. You’re welcome to use it, but you don’t have to.

If you have any questions or concerns, just let us know. We’d also love to hear any feedback you have.

Information on Critiques

Written on 04.11.26 by Sumair Ijaz Hashmi

Dear all,

The slides from last session (on how to critique a paper) and the grading criteria for critiques are also on CMS. These are the main documents which you need to write down your critiques for this proseminar.

We’ve posted example critiques for the two papers we’ve already discussed: the… Read more

Dear all,

The slides from last session (on how to critique a paper) and the grading criteria for critiques are also on CMS. These are the main documents which you need to write down your critiques for this proseminar.

We’ve posted example critiques for the two papers we’ve already discussed: the Experts vs. Non-Experts paper and the Forced PINs paper. You’ll find them in the Materials tab on CMS and on the discussion forum. These examples are for inspiration only. They are not a gold standard, and you don’t need to follow the same structure or line of thinking we used. Please don’t copy our sentences and fill them in with details from the paper you’re reviewing.

Using these materials, please write your first critique on any one compulsory paper from the Hate and Harassment module. To submit:

  1. Upload a PDF to CMS by 3:00 PM on Monday, 9 November. The assignment tab will appear soon.
  2. After the 3:00 PM deadline, post your critique on the public forum in the thread titled “Hate & Harassment.”

Once again, the use of AI tools or copying from each other is strictly prohibited.

If you have any questions, please reach out. Best of luck!

Session leads have been finalized

Written on 28.10.26 by Taha Taha

Hello everyone,

The session leads (presenters) have been updated in the CMS Home page. Please find your name in the last column of the "Session Breakdown" table: https://cms.cispa.saarland/usld/

Feel free to reach out if you have any questions or concerns.

Good luck preparing for your… Read more

Hello everyone,

The session leads (presenters) have been updated in the CMS Home page. Please find your name in the last column of the "Session Breakdown" table: https://cms.cispa.saarland/usld/

Feel free to reach out if you have any questions or concerns.

Good luck preparing for your presentations! We are super excited to see your presentations smiley

Best,

Course Team

3 November Session

Written on 28.10.26 by Sumair Ijaz Hashmi

Hello everyone,

Next week, we will go over techniques for critiquing a research paper, which you will need to use when writing your critiques for each module. Please read the compulsory reading in the CMS before the session. No critique is due for the next session.

27th October Session + Module Preference Form

Written on 21.10.26 by Taha Taha

Hello everyone,

Next week, we will go over techniques for reading research papers and discuss the structure of a research paper. Please read the two compulsory readings in the CMS before the session. No critique is due for the next session.

Please submit your module preferences using this form: … Read more

Hello everyone,

Next week, we will go over techniques for reading research papers and discuss the structure of a research paper. Please read the two compulsory readings in the CMS before the session. No critique is due for the next session.

Please submit your module preferences using this form: https://cispa.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_2nu1YrpeJmPtq62

Deadline: Tuesday, 27th October

Before filling it out, we recommend skimming the abstracts of the readings in the modules that interest you. Then select your top 3 preferences, in order, in the Qualtrics form. Please note we will do our best to assign you your most preferred module, but we cannot guarantee your first choice. Moreover, preferences cannot be changed once the form is submitted, so please choose carefully. Lastly, please submit the form only once. Duplicate responses will not be accepted.

If you have any questions, feel free to reach us at proseminar_usable_security@cispa.de 

See you next week!

Show all

Content

This course explores usable security and privacy, a field that examines how people interact with security & privacy technologies, and how those technologies can be designed to actually work for them. Across the semester we will read and discuss papers from the last decade (2016-2026) covering subfields, such as security advice, authentication, scams & fraud, privacy & consent, at-risk users, and emerging threats to name a few. Students will learn to read papers critically, connect findings across the broader field, and present research effectively to their peers.

 

Time & Location

The seminar meets weekly on Tuesdays, 10:00 am – 12:00 pm
Location: CISPA  C0 - 0.01 Presentation Room, Stuhlsatzenhaus 5, 66123 Saarbrücken.

 

Learning Outcomes

Students will learn:

  • About topics usable security and privacy delves into
  • To read papers effectively
  • To analyze papers
  • To present papers

 

Grading

  • Research paper critiques: 40%
  • Paper presentation: 40%
  • Class participation: 10%
  • Attendance: 10%

 

Class Structure

 The course runs as weekly, module-based sessions. Each module corresponds to one subfield within usable security and privacy. 

ATTENDANCE IS MANDATORY. If you cannot attend on these dates, please don't register for the seminar.

 

Critiques

Each week's module comes with 3 readings: 2 compulsory and 1 optional. Every week, students will be required to submit a critique on one of the compulsory readings for that week's module. The critique for the week will be due on  Sundays 5 PM  before every session. Since each session happens on a Tuesday , and the critique is due the Sunday before at 5 PM , that means the deadline falls on two days before the week's session.

All students submit a critique on one of the compulsory readings via CMS AND publicly in a discussion forum before the presentation day.

Instructions on how to write a critique will be provided in the first few sessions and will be made available in the Materials tab.

 

Presentations

Every module will be a student-led discussion and presentation of that week's compulsory  readings. One student presents the  compulsory readings for that module. As pointed out in the section above, each week's module comes with 3 readings: 2 compulsory and 1 optional. Rather than presenting each paper separately, the presenter is expected to synthesize the compulsory readings of that week's readings into a single, cohesive talk. The presentation should draw connections across the papers, weaving them into one narrative about the module's topic rather than summarizing them one by one.

The presenter may incorporate classmates' critiques into their presentation, if they choose to. Students are encouraged, but not required, to conduct additional research on current affairs and additional papers to strengthen their talk as they see fit.

Students will be judged on content, clarity, interactiveness, ability to tackle questions, and engagement with external materials.

More details on how to present the module, including an example presentation, will be provided in the sessions. A grading rubric will also be made available in the Materials tab.

 

Session Breakdown

Date Module Readings Session Lead Room
October 20, 2026 Introduction Lecture — Course Team C0-0.01
27 Oct 2026 Reading and Analyzing Papers

Compulsory  How to read a paper

Compulsory End User and Expert Perceptions of Threats and Potential Countermeasures — IEEE Euro S&P Workshop 2020

Course Team C0-0.01
3 Nov 2026 Learning How to Criticize a Paper Compulsory Use the Force: Evaluating Force-Sensitive Authentication for Mobile Devices — SOUPS 2016 Course Team C0-0.01
November 10, 2026 Hate & Harassment (model presentation) Compulsory “It's common and a part of being a content creator”: Understanding How Creators Experience and Cope with Hate and Harassment Online — CHI 2022
Compulsory “They Don't Leave Us Alone Anywhere We Go”: Gender and Digital Abuse in South Asia — CHI 2019
Optional “A Stalker's Paradise”: How Intimate Partner Abusers Exploit Technology — CHI 2018
Course Team C0-0.01
November 17, 2026 Scams & Fraud Compulsory Users Really Do Plug in USB Drives They Find — IEEE S&P 2016
Compulsory Users Really Do Answer Telephone Scams — USENIX Security 2019
Optional Experiences with Digital Scams Post-Incarceration in the US — SOUPS 2026

Eric Theisen

C0-0.01
November 24, 2026 Security Advice Compulsory How I Learned to be Secure: a Census-Representative Survey of Security Advice Sources and Behavior — CCS 2016
Compulsory “I Wonder if These Warnings Are Accurate”: Security and Privacy Advice in Nine Majority World Countries — USENIX Security 2026
Optional “…No one can hack my Mind”: Comparing Expert and Non-Expert Security Practices — SOUPS 2015

Bowen Shi

C0-0.01
1 Dec 2026 Authentication & Credentials Compulsory Better Managed than Memorized? Studying the Impact of Managers on Password Strength and Reuse — USENIX Security 2018
Compulsory Is FIDO2 the Kingslayer of User Authentication? A Comparative Usability Study of FIDO2 Passwordless Authentication — IEEE S&P 2020
Optional A Usability Study of Five Two-Factor Authentication Methods — SOUPS 2019

Aicha Nidam

C0-0.02
December 8, 2026 Research Methods Compulsory Replication: “No One Can Hack My Mind” – 10 Years Later: An Update and Outlook on Experts' and Non-Experts' Security Practices and Advice — SOUPS 2025
Compulsory How Well Do My Results Generalize? Comparing Security and Privacy Survey Results from MTurk, Web, and Telephone Samples — IEEE S&P 2019
Optional Different Researchers, Different Results? Analyzing the Influence of Researcher Experience and Data Type During Qualitative Analysis of an Interview and Survey Study on Security Advice — CHI 2023

Leon Müller

C0-0.01
December 15, 2026 Privacy & Consent Compulsory (Un)informed Consent: Studying GDPR Consent Notices in the Field — CCS 2019
Compulsory Dark Patterns after the GDPR: Scraping Consent Pop-ups and Demonstrating Their Influence — CHI 2020
Optional An Empirical Analysis of Data Deletion and Opt-Out Choices on 150 Websites — SOUPS 2019

Tim Loell

Room 0.08 in E1 7
Christmas Break: 21 December 2026 - 3 January 2027  
January 5, 2027 At-Risk Users Compulsory “ In Eighty Percent of the Cases, I Select the Password for Them”: Security and Privacy Challenges, Advice, and Opportunities at Cybercafes in Kenya — IEEE S&P 2024
Compulsory SoK: A Framework for Unifying At-Risk User Research — IEEE S&P 2022
Optional How WEIRD Is Usable Privacy and Security Research? — USENIX Security 2024

Karmaa Sherpa

C0-0.01
January 12, 2027 Emerging Threats Compulsory “Did They F***ing Consent to That?”: Safer Digital Intimacy via Proactive Protection Against Image-Based Sexual Abuse — USENIX Security 2024
Compulsory Mental Models, Expectations and Implications of Client-Side Scanning: An Interview Study with Experts — CHI 2024
Optional In Focus, Out of Privacy: The Wearer's Perspective on the Privacy Dilemma of Camera Glasses — CHI 2024

Amic Kumar Goyal

C0 - 0.01
January 19, 2027 Developers & Experts Compulsory “If HTTPS Were Secure, I Wouldn't Need 2FA”: End User and Administrator Mental Models of HTTPS — IEEE S&P 2020
Compulsory Comparing the Usability of Cryptographic APIs — IEEE S&P 2017
Optional To Cloud or Not to Cloud: A Qualitative Study on Self-Hosters' Motivation, Operation, and Security Mindset — USENIX Security 2023

Hamid Hatam

C0-0.01
January 26, 2027 Free Lecture —

—

C0-0.01

 

 

Academic Dishonesty

In this course, you will be reading a wide range of scholarly sources and will work to integrate these concepts into your own research, critiques and professional practice. It is imperative that any use of others' intellectual work (including, but not limited to, quotations, paraphrasing of ideas, figures, models) be accompanied by an appropriate citation or reference. The course follows Saarland University and DFG's guidelines regarding academic dishonesty: https://www.uni-saarland.de/en/administration/research-integrity.html 

Any form of cheating will result in a penalty up to automatic fail grade for the course. All instances of cheating will be forwarded to the associated university body for appropriate disciplinary action.

Helping another student to cheat and cheating are considered equal cases of academic dishonesty and will be treated as outlined above.

Giving another student an electronic copy of your homework, or access to your computer account constitutes cheating on your behalf if that other student copies or uses any files that become implicated in a cheating case.

 

AI Policy

The use of AI tools (eg, ChatGPT, Claude, or similar) is strictly prohibited for all coursework in this seminar, including critiques and presentations. All critiques and presentation content must be the student's own original work and analysis. Any case of plagiarism will be reported directly to the Examination Office.

 

Accessibility

If you anticipate or experience physical or academic barriers based on disability, you are welcome to let us know so that we can discuss options (such as live captions during class). You are also encouraged to contact the Equal Opportunities and Diversity Management Unit at: ksb@uni-saarland.de.

 

Student with Disabilities

If you have a disability that requires special academic accommodation, please make an appointment to speak with us within the first three (3) weeks of the semester in order to discuss any adjustments. It is important that we talk about this at the beginning of the semester. It is the student's responsibility to notify the Equal Opportunities and Diversity Management Unit (https://www.uni-saarland.de/en/administration/diversity/inclusive-education.html) of an impairment/condition that may require accommodations and/or classroom modifications.

 

Mental Health

If you find yourself beginning to feel some stress, anxiety and/or slightly feeling overwhelmed, please contact the counseling service made available to students through the university: https://www.stw-saarland.de/beratung/

 

Harassment Policy

We are committed to providing a safe and secure classroom environment for our students. Any kind of harassment or violent behavior is strictly prohibited and will be promptly reported to the Gender Equality Office (https://www.uni-saarland.de/en/administration/gender-equality-office.html).

 

Questions

We will make use of a discussion forum to ask questions about the course modules and for students to submit their critiques publicly. We encourage all questions to be asked via this discussion forum so that everyone can learn from each other. For questions that you are not comfortable asking publicly, please reach out at the following email address:  proseminar_usable_security@cispa.de 

 

Privacy Policy | Legal Notice
If you encounter technical problems, please contact the administrators.